Life throws some tough dilemmas your way. As if your everyday moral questions were not enough, history brought people to a crossroads which surely disturbed them in one way or the other. And sometimes the choices you make tell a lot about where you stand. Especially if they happen to be Pakistanis who are secular liberals and anti-establishment.
To support Maulana’s Azadi March or not.
There are many secular leftists who have simply rejected the idea of a Maulana vehicle being an ideal platform for the promotion of democracy. The likes of the Awami Workers Party and Jibran Nasir, who are always proactive on social issues, chose not to support the march because of the religious card, bigotry against Ahmedis, and the exclusion of women from the platform, something which Marvi Sirmed also pointed out.
Looking at the “Azadi March” from afar, one thing is clear to me. In the democracy that Maulana sahib is fight for, women would have no place. Even if they manage to get there, women would be backstage or at a far & dark corner.
Ask yourselves dear democrats, do we want THIS?— Marvi Sirmed (@marvisirmed) October 30, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
There has been a lot of confusion regarding supposed Left/liberal support for the Azadi March. Watch @Ziyad_F explain the two actual positions taken by the handful of progressives left in this country. (And don’t let the title mis-lead you!) https://t.co/yLtZ3LlIZn
— Nida Kirmani (@nidkirm) October 25, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
I wish it were that simple. While I do hope the Azadi March weakens the grip of the establishment & their puppets, I am also conscious that the men leading this march have a very different definition of democracy than I do. Empowering them could harm us later on.
— Nida Kirmani (@nidkirm) October 30, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Most of the pro-establishment and/or pro-status quo or pro-Imran Khan liberals completely reject the notion of the Azadi March because it is being led by a religious party or because of the “religious card.” The religious card here particularly being focus on preserving the finality of Prophethood or Khatm-e-Nabuwat, a fancy name of the anti-Ahmedi movement in Pakistan, and against attempts to amend the blasphemy law. Many of these critics agree that anti-establishment liberals are compromising their principles by cheering for Maulana’s march.
Everyone subscribes to their own version of the doctrine of necessity, be they from left or right, progressive or conservative. Only very few recognise that, and fewer yet admit to it.
— Zarrar Khuhro (@ZarrarKhuhro) October 16, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
‘This march is against those who released asia bibi and wajih ul hasan and those who oppose khatm e nabuwat’ jui f maulana aziz ahmed ashrafi on @ZaraHatKay_Dawn right now
— Zarrar Khuhro (@ZarrarKhuhro) October 16, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Other anti-establishment center-left and right liberals, especially those sympathetic to the current cause of PML-N leader Nawaz Sharif and the emerging anti-establishment leadership of Maryam Nawaz, are not playing so safe. They are fully behind the march and even taking jabs at those sitting out citing the religious card, including the pro-establishment liberals who are subtly supporting the Imran Khan administration.
Liberals are conflicted and divided over supporting, conditionally supporting or condemning the Azadi March. But it’s a bit rich for a party that allied with the JI in KP and funded the more extreme Samiul Haq to judge others for ‘supporting religious extremists and bigots’
— Talat Aslam (@titojourno) October 31, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
“لاہور استقبالی کیمپ کی حالت دیکھی؟ ایک لیڈر نہیں وہاں اور 40 بندے”
لعنت آپ پہ ۔لعنت ۔ لعنت ۔لعنت
— Gul Bukhari (@GulBukhari) October 29, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
The politically incorrect Gul Bukhari is, of course, all for the march and disappointment at the PML-N for their half-hearted support.
سوال: تو پی ٹی ایم خود کو اس دھرنے اور مارچ سے الگ رکھے گی؟
علی وزیر: بالکل۔ ہمارا فیصلہ ہوا ہے کہ ہم ایسے نظام کا کبھی ساتھ نہیں دیں گے جو ایک متروک نظام ہو۔
😏🤷🏻♀️
(اور یوں آج پاکستانی میڈیا میں #PTM کا نام لینا اور اس کے رکن قومی اسمبلی کا مؤقف سنوانا جائز ٹھہرا 🤓)#AzadiMarch https://t.co/Au0rfPuSz1 pic.twitter.com/lDiHBFZYjq— افشاں مصعب (@AfshanMasab) October 30, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
The PTM has distanced itself from the march citing its impact of perpetuating an “obsolete system of government,” albeit supporting their right to protest. PML-N and PPP, meanwhile, are partially participating and avoiding the march for some mysterious reasons only known to them.
Talked to participants.
PML-N welcomed the march in Lahore but didn’t join the march. So far only PkMAP & ANP seem to have actively joined the march.
PPP & PML-N aren’t sincerely on board but have maintained nominal presence just to claim credit in case the march succeedes. https://t.co/CPsH9MvBRE
— R Kakar (@rafiullahkakar) October 30, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Conspicuous by its absence is the PMLN leadership
ارے بھائی ہسپتال اور جیل میں آپ کے لیڈروں کے ساتھ ظلم ہورہا ہے یا مولانا کے؟ #Azadi_March_Updates— Mohammad Taqi (@mazdaki) October 30, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
Many anti-establishment seculars tend to agree but acknowledge at the back of their minds that some kind of resistance needs to be offered to the current government.
We request PTM leadership & comrade to join Azdi March in the interest of Pakistan. Its a public demand as many other look confused. https://t.co/QEKndo0UOB
— Lal (@lalaquar) October 31, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
There have been no shortages of false comparisons with the Khomeini-led revolution in Iran to discredit the march and even dismissals mentioning that it is no Hong Kong or Beirut protest. Indeed this march is neither. But surely, it has been facing a media blackout which has become the characteristic of the Bajwa-Imran regime. These visuals were nowhere to be seen on national TV.
عمرانی دھرنے کو صبح سے شام اور شام سے صبح تک کورج دینے والا میڈیا آزادی مارچ کا ٹھاٹھیں مارتا ہوا عوامی سمندر نظر نہیں آرہا ؟ pic.twitter.com/YOqEFY2AAt
— Mian Iftikhar Husain (@MianIftikharHus) October 30, 2019
آزادی مارچ کارواں ۔ ۔ ۔#عوامی_سمندر_اسلام_آباد_کی_طرف pic.twitter.com/MBVLNrqk4T
— Maulana Fazl-ur-Rehman (@MoulanaOfficial) October 28, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
یہ صرف ضلع پشاور کا جلوس ہے جو ابھی تک رشکئی انٹرچینج تک پہنچ چکا ہے،رشکئی انٹرچینج میں اب دیگر اضلاع کے قافلے مرکزی جلوس کے ساتھ شامل ہوتے ہوئے ملی مشر اسفندیار ولی خان کی قیادت میں اسلام آباد کا رخ کرینگے#استعفی_تمھارا_باپ_بھی_دیگا pic.twitter.com/0UEIvcMWvP
— Awami National Party (@ANPMarkaz) October 31, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
As of today, the Awami National Party, which is as secular a party as they come in Pakistan, Another secular nationalist party Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party (PKMAP) of Mehmood Khan Achakzai had joined the march right from the start in Karachi on October 27.
Pkmap of Mahmood Achakzai has been the 2nd largest party of march ❤️
Proud to be worker of a party that has always shown resistance against non democratic forces #ChalloAzadiMarchKeSath pic.twitter.com/bABeiatNeO— Muzamil Shah (@watanyar07) October 30, 2019
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
The Maulana’s caravans might enter Islamabad any hour now and the procession which was supposed to happen today has been delayed until Friday afternoon prayers, partially because of the Rahimyar Khan train tragedy.
It is clear that Maulana’s party does not see this march as a mission to enforce Sharia in the country, as much as some people trying to make it sound like that. It is indeed not directed against the military but it does channel some of the frustration of the public against the Imran Khan administration, if not against the Bajwa-Imran regime. It may occasionally mention the selectors but it is surely not against them.
So are you supporting the March too? I am not “supporting” a Mulllah’s party either but I sure as well don’t mind it is happening. And pretty much agree with all its objectives other than “protecting the Islamic provisions of the constitution.” If the capital can be paralyzed for the good part of the year for discrediting a legitimately elected government and for rigging allegations for four constituencies, it can surely be shut down for locking up the entire opposition and almost killing a three-times elected Prime Minister. And the latter is my biggest reason to march against the current administration.
The only problem is that the agenda of this march barely mentions that.
Filed under: Commentary, Videos | Tagged: ANP, anti-establishment, authoritarianism, Azadi March, Bajwa-Imran regime, blasphemy, centrism, centrist, conservative, democracy, government, Imran Khan, Islamabad, Islamic Republic, Jamiat-e-Ulema Islam, JUI (F), liberal, march, Maulana Fazl-ur-Rehman, military establishment, Nawaz Sharif, opposition, Pakistan, PKMAP, PML-N, politics, PPP, pro-establishment, protest, PTI, religion, religion card, secular, Secularism, Sharia, support, theocratic, tweets | Leave a comment »
Giving Democracy the Boot
Source: Dawn
Faisal Vawda, the PTI Minister of Water Resources, and known for his signature outrageous antics, made a new history along with provocative ARY News anchor Kashif Abbasi. In a talk show, which also featured opposition leaders Senator Javed Abbasi of the PML-N and Qamar Zaman Kaira of the PPP on the panel.
In the middle of the talk show, Faisal Vawda took out a military boot, symbolic of the Pakistani military, and put it on the panel desk. Both the opposition leaders walked out in protest. This was meant to insult the reversal of PML-N on their anti-military stance as well as the corruption of their leaders, who have supposedly made another deal with the military establishment to flee the country. All this while, the PTI ministers have been criticizing the PML-N leader Nawaz Sharif for fleeing the country under the false pretense of medical reasons.
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
As insulting, idiotic, and completely reckless Vawda’s “boot ko izzat do” action is, being our last Pakistani Idiot of the Year, his comments in the show remind the opposition of a harsh reality. The PML-N leadership has forsaken its anti-establishment workers and left them hanging while conveniently abandoning their criticism of the military leadership in exchange for Nawaz Sharif’s departure to London for medical treatment. It was on social media, that their anti-establishment supporters had started the criticism of “boot ko izzat do” (Give respect to the boot (military establishment)) as a spinoff of “vote ko izzat do” (Give respect to the vote) which was the slogan of PML-N in the 2018 elections. It is not as if the phrase was coined by Vawda.
Kashif Abbasi, the ARY News anchor, the look on whose face was worth watching, probably did the right thing to let Vawda make his point from a broadcaster’s viewpoint. It certainly created broadcast history no matter how terrible it was for political discourse in the country. However, PEMRA had slapped Abbasi with a 60-day ban, which will be reviewed. On the other side, Imran Khan, the Prime Minister, has expressed his displeasure over Vawda’s behavior in the talk show and imposed a ban on him on appearing on talk shows.
https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js
The Vawda boot episode only goes to show the dismal state of democracy and civilian supremacy in Pakistan in which the deep state and its representatives have dropped all pretense about their interference in politics. It is symptomatic of this disregard of the constitutional roles of institutions which has enabled a loudmouth such as Vawda to indulge in this shameless behavior. However, you could argue that there was a lot of truth in Vawda’s rant.
Which makes you wonder if Vawda is the only political leader brave enough to even mention the involvement of the “boot” in politics on mainstream media so openly.
Perhaps he is a free-speech hero and not an idiot after all.
Share this:
Filed under: Commentary, Videos | Tagged: ARY News, boot, boot ko izzat do, civilian supremacy, Faisal Vawda, free speech, Javed Abbasi, Kashif Abbasi, military, military establishment, PML-N, politics, PPP, PTI, Qamar Zaman Kair, talk show | Leave a comment »